Carbon Tracker Says Renewables Are Better Than Coal In Every Category Imaginable

Renewables Continue To Increase Their Cost Competitiveness Versus Coal, With 27% Of The Global Coal Fleet Unprofitable Today

Do Not Revive Coal is the third annual report in Carbon Tracker’s Powering Down Coal series. The report finds around 70% of the global fleet relies to some degree on policy support and would likely be unprofitable in the absence of market distortions. Coal is increasingly unviable both financially and environmentally and is ceasing to make sense as an option for investors and governments.

The analysis finds that investments in new renewables beat investments in new coal in all major markets when comparing the levelized cost of energy (LCOE) for both. The cost competitiveness of renewables versus global coal operating fleet is growing as well. Today, new renewables beat 77% of operating coal, and this will rise to 98% by 2026 and 99% by 2030 based on current pollution regulations and climate policies when comparing the LCOE of new renewables to the long-run marginal cost (LRMC) of existing coal units as shown below.

Data Source: Carbon Tracker Analysis

The report highlights that five Asian countries — China, India, Vietnam, Indonesia, and Japan — are responsible for 80% of the world’s planned new coal plants and 75% of existing coal capacity. In these five countries, 92% of planned coal units will be uneconomic, even under business as usual, and up to US$150 billion could be wasted.

Data Source: Carbon Tracker Analysis, GEM

Here are several of the high-level recommendations the report lays down for investors and policymakers:

  • Cancel all new projects or face US$150 billion in value destruction for investors and taxpayers.
  • Governments should use post-COVID-19 stimulus as an opportunity to lay the foundations for a sustainable energy system.
  • Enabling market design with a level playing field allows continued growth of renewables at the least cost.
  • In many cases, especially in Asia, governments should resist the urge to switch from coal to liquefied natural gas (LNG).